Wednesday, September 17, 2008

Our families Journey Part 2

Later that night, I could not sleep. I kept replaying things over in my head. Trying to find a solution. There had to be something we could do. Having no idea where to go next. Ian and I felt like our hands were tied. Q had been tested for ADHD in the past (twice). We were told he did not have it. The questions were just stuck in the air. If Q is not ADHD, then what is the problem? Could there be some other issue? There had to be someone in the school system that could help us. Help Q. Not knowing what else to do, we just started dancing. Sending Q out the door, waiting for him to return with today's issues. It got to the point where I hated sending Q to school. He hated going. At least on that we agreed. Towards the end of the school year, I had to drop paperwork off at the school. I noticed Q's class in the lunch room and decided to stop in.
As I walked across the lunchroom his teacher noticed me. I could see the visible change in her demeanor. As I approached her, she immediately became defensive. She asked (OK, demanded) that I step into the hall. She needed to speak with me. Out we went, I knew what was coming. Sure enough she says "Q will not do what is required in computer lab". I thanked her, yet again I assured her we would talk to Q. And that is what we did.
Q came home and I was FUMING! "What is going on with you"? "Why can't you just sit there and do your work"? "That's it, you are grounded"! Somewhere in all of this Q just started crying, I could see him getting upset. "Mom, I did the stupid work". "Well then why is Mrs. R saying you didn't? "I don't know mom, I finished that stupid book months ago". WHAT? What are you talking about? "Mrs. R just told me you are not doing what you need to in computer lab". "Mom, she wants me to sit quiet and do NOTHING". "That's not true, there has to be another book you can do". "NO, Mom, there isn't. Mrs. R told me if she gives me the book there won't be anything for me to do in 5 TH grade". At this point I was ANGRY. I decided we needed to calm down. Food always solves everything. I made a snack, and we sat down. And, for the first time I listened to my son. Really listened. For the first time I heard my son. I remember calling Ian at some point and I was SCREAMING into the phone. After calming me down, and getting the gist of what I was trying to say (in between my rants and not so pretty language) we decided that we would keep Q up that night and all 3 talk. I let the matter go, sent Q to play and sat on my sofa fuming. Ranting to myself. Later that night Ian and I would come to learn more and more about our sons school year.
The next time his teacher and I had occasion to meet I was a different mother. I was armed with questions? This time we would dance alright. BUT, I would be leading. And, the dance would be of my choosing. I have to say the meeting was for the most part one sided. I asked questions. Why is he not given something to DO during computer lab? The answer was the same, they could not allow him to advance to far. Well then can we find another class for him to attend? NOPE. OK, what about all his other classes? Is he ahead in those as well? (I already knew the answer, after Ian and I talked to Q) Well, we work as a class. OK, so you are telling me that he CAN'T learn to fast, so we can convenience the school? That was pretty much what they were telling me. I demanded they look at his test scores. Was told they can't accept scores based on tests not administered at the school. I felt like I was banging my head against the wall.
After that meeting, Ian and I decided to have a meeting with the counselor. This time Ian would be in attendance. For those of you that read this and know us INR, you know Ian. He is quiet and reserved. Pirate Boy had a first grade teacher who told me once, "you know the kids all get a class made book and I have allowed them to each pick 4 friends they want pictures of in their books. Pirate Boy is my only student that every kid in the class picked". Well that is Ian, Pirate Boy is our carbon copy of his daddy. In EVERY way. BUT, when Ian gets upset watch out. I have heard many a story about my husband at work. He is THE guy they all go to for everything (believe me, my phone bill proves it). He will bend over back words to help them. Having said that Ian has no problem flexing his proverbial muscles when the need arises.
Going into this meeting Ian took charge. (he has a way of doing that). Firing a barge of questions at the counselor. To which she had no reply or acceptable answers. They would agree to test Q but the school year would be ending in a few weeks so he would probably just have to be tested again next year. Her reason "because kids loose what they have learned over the summer". We left that meeting ANGRY! I have always felt anger was a useless emotion. After all psychologist tell us anger is really just other emotions we have manifested as anger. Well not in this case. It was PURE ANGER!
Later that night I could not sleep. I was still fuming. The Internet was my saving grace. I began researching educational options. I googled online school. The first thing that popped up was a home school site. And, I clicked on it. Reading story after story about home schooling. That was also the night I found Amy's blog http://www.thefoilhat.com/. I read and read. (and laughed my butt off) Ian came in somewhere around 4 am asking what the heck I was doing. "Look, this lady has 4 boys and she home schools them". Ian went back to bed. There I sat, reading. I also found my way to Doc's. Reading her blog, and a few others. It was a lifeline. I spent the next week scouring the Internet. Drinking in all the information on home schooling. Talking to Ian (I mean I talked, and talked, and talked) about it. Could we do this? Would it make a difference?
In the end, we decided to send him to 5 TH grade. All the while I was ordering curriculum. I think some time during that summer I decided he would be home schooled. Once the testing for 5 TH grade was complete, my decision was made. Here was our son testing in the 90 TH percentile fighting for an education.
I called the school, informed them he would not be returning. (I had spoken with our hs rep here, she assured me they would not haul us off to the big house). And off we went. I have to admit that first few days I kept waiting for that knock on the door. "you must send your child to school". That knock never came.
Q and I started off slow. Testing him to see what he needed to work on. Talking to him to see what he wanted to learn. I remember that "moment" (you know the one, where you just say I GOT IT). That came one morning I walked into the living room and there on my floor was my oldest son reading a book on the Maya people. "Look mom, I wrote this paper". I just stood there reading this paper (full of grammatical errors) and smiling to myself. It was beautiful. Public School moms keep every scrap of work from Kindergarten. Well I was framing this. I gave Q his paper back, and he kept right on going. Retreating to my room for a good cry. In that moment I made one final decision. My kids education would never again be a compromised. No teacher would ever know my kids better then I did. I would NEVER again dance their dance. From now on I would be in charge.
Today my boys are both in public school. On a modified schedule. I sit on the PTO and SAC boards for both their schools. There is also one other mom who world schools her kids. (world school is what Q calls it. He has pointed out that most of his school is not done at home) They attend on a similar schedule as my boys. Nothing will ever be perfect. No system is infallible. What I have learned about teachers is simple. We are all teachers on some level or another. The ones that teach in a concrete building either love what they do, or are there for their summers off. We are blessed this year Q had a science teacher that loves what he does. It shows. They are hands on, if the kids really enjoy something they keep going. His class is student interest based. I think they spend half their day outside. After meeting with him, Ian and I understand what a wonderful teacher can give our son. Maybe some day public education of our children will be competitive, and worth it.
All of the hard learned lessons have benefited Pirate Boy. Reading at an advanced level (for public school kids) yet still having writing issues Ian and I have taken the lead. This time around we feel better armed with the knowledge that public school is a "warehouse approach to education". There are services he needs that I am not equipped to give him. I know a lot of home school moms will read that and think I have learned nothing. Not so. This past years journey was also a reflection of my abilities as a mother/teacher. He needs therapies that I can not give him. What he also needs is me in his corner. Fighting every step of the way. His teacher this year is a wonderful woman who loves what she does. She understands what our goals for Pirate Boy are. She is 100% behind our decision to only send him for part of the day.
What comes next for our kids on their journey of world school is totally up to us as a family.
Where the military moves us next will determine how much of the public school resources we use. I have to say if we were in the states and had a network of home schooling families, or resources to select from I don't think they would attend school at all. Those decisions will come in time. For now, for this year, it's working.
My advice to people who are thinking about home schooling, is give it a try. Take a week, a month, or a year. Spend your days with your kids. Learn how they learn. Watch the wheels turn, and yes even watch them fail. Understand what your child loves and hates about learning and foster his/her loves. Trying to force a kid that hates something to "just do it" will never work. Allow your kids to have a voice. Every day I am amazed at how intuitive my kids are. At how well they know themselves. The other day PB said to me "mommy, I have decided I don't want to be an Army man anymore". (inside I was thanking God). "Well, what do you want to be"? "I want to be a writer". I thought to myself in that moment. If Ian and I didn't foster his love for stories, and words would he want this. If we were to spend the next few years making him try harder, and harping on the handwriting would he just give up? Pirate Boy knows and understands how hard writing is for him. We just find ways to work through it.
I still read all those blogs about home school families. Now a days I shake my head, saying to myself been there, doing that.
This is a looooong winded answer, but I am a long winded person. Thanks for reading....

20 comments:

SuburbanCorrespondent said...

Most school districts here in the states don't give you that part time option. I've never even heard of it! But there are a ton of other resources, so it evens out, I'm sure.

And you're right - the best thing is learning how your kid learns. It is so much fun.

Lynnie said...

You're sooooooooo lucky that you have the option to stay home with them part time and homeschool them! Having taught Kindergarten-3rd grade, I have seen several kids in Q's situation. Very advanced kids who were bored and needing extra challenge. With 25 kids in a class, it is really hard to meet everyone's needs.

Reading about the computer lab in your story made me cringe. I remember trying to teach 25 5-year-olds who had never seen a computer before how to "log on". 75% were "just sitting there" while I tried to help a few kids find letters and reboot a couple computers with problems! And then our half hour would be up!

I think the way schools are set up, it is just impossible to keep 25 kids progressing at their own pace. But I LOVED teaching and I have to say, I had a LOT of patience for the "wiggly" kids. I just didn't care that they moved around so much because I knew they couldn't help it.

Good luck in always finding the balance! And who cares if you get off-balance sometimes and have to backtrack or reconsider some ideas. That's life, and good for you boys to see that you can change your mind about things.

Interesting story!

K8E said...

Yay! I love happy endings. :)

Tabi said...

I am just stunned with the school system that you had to deal with!! Around here if you are that advanced in your school work and stuff they just go ahead and move you up to the next grade! That is crazy to hold a student back because they are learning too fast and then to make them get into trouble because they won't sit perfectly still b/c you refuse to give them any more work!! ARGH!! I am just mad thinking about it so I can't even imagine how you guys felt!
Thank God you had the option to be able to have an alternative route! Thanks for answering my question!! Who knew it would have ended in two great blogs!! LOL Go me!! haha!

obimomkenobi said...

I think you learned quite a bit homeschooling Q - about learning to respond to your kids' needs and not a school districts. You USE the school your kids are in; they don't use your kids. I think that's the greatest lesson of all from homeschooling.

A head's up to Suburban Correspondent: the school districts in my state require schools to provide "as desired" education for all homeschooling families - specific classes, clubs, services and sports participation at the homeschooling families' request. Most school districts here don't advertise this fact, but they are legally bound to it.

American in Norway said...

I am sitting here in TEARS... this is TOTALLY the same thing I am going through with Dane. This year, once again, we hoped he would have a teacher who understands him... although she is better than the teacher he had the past 2 years... we still haven't found our answer. Dane started school in the U.S. his teacher was the one to realize how advanced he was... they had him tested within the first few weeks of school & he was placed in a special program 2 days a week... where they encouraged him to go further... to think out of the box. Here in Norway... we got... "ya, great he is smart... but he needs to be quiet..." he isn't even allowed to participate in his English class because, obviously he knows all of the answers.... but really how boring... & they wonder why he can't sit still & be quiet.

I don't know about home schooling here... & I think Dane needs the social aspect of school, but I really want to talk to you more about this... FINALLY someone going through the exact same thing!

Jena said...

wow, what a great story. Thanks so much for putting it all down for us. We can do part time school here in my district too (in Illinois) but it's not required of every district. I'm glad we have that option. Congratulations on your success! And thank you for visiting my blog and leaving a comment. :) I love to hear how parents are thinking rationally and proactively about their kids. Teachers are just people. :)

Aiden said...

Loved reading your story and how God led you to homeschooling!!

~Jeanne

christine said...

We also have "part time" schooling in Iowa, it's called Dual Enrollment here. A parent can enroll their child in just about anything the school offers, even sports.

I'm glad to hear you have found what works for your family. That is the most important thing of all, each family has their own way.

Ami said...

:::cheering:::

I love reading other people's stories about how they ended up homeschooling.

Your story has less profanity than mine.

:)

Wendy Hawksley said...

These stories are part of the reason we decided to homeschool even before we knew we wanted a child!

It is great to have wonderful people, such as Doc, Ami, and yourself, sharing their experiences, so others might also realze that they need to stick their children with a second-rate, one-size-fits-all educational mentality.

You chose not to deal with "No Child Left Behind", but rather to fight for your child to be able to move on ahead! :-)

hollysjoy said...

That's a amazing story, thanks for sharing.

As a faormer teacher, here in the U.S., most of my friends are teachers, and really don't get why I hs. Yet, they know what the schools are like. I'm amazed they don't. We mostly agree to disagree or we couldn't be friends :-). Some are a little jealous that they don't have the . . . I don't know what to do it themselves.

Bluegrassmama said...

I am so glad that it worked out for you guys! Our childrens education is one of the most important things that parents have to deal with. Where we live we have a wonderful school that teaches grades K-8. The high school is horrible though, so we don't know what we will be doing about that yet.

The Cooking Lady said...

We are entering our 5th year fo home schooling. My son is 19 and autistic. If I can homeschool, you can certainly homeschool.

We use no certain cirriculum(sp?). We went to Sam's, BJ,'s and other schooling bookstores. We wing it and are considered eclctic(sp?) homeschoolers.

My daughter, who is entering 9th grade this year has only one text bok in which she schools from. Two credite classes are online. Try FLVS(Florida Virtual School) For Floridians it is free, but out of staters have a fee to pay, not sure what that is.

I wish now I had homeschooled earlier.But such is life. We have filed trips, go to plays, we have Science Fair, Literary Fair, International Night, Spelling Bee, and Brain Bowl(A reverse Jeopardy).

So our group lacks for nothing. There is so much out there and keeping a chhild like yours in the public school system will only heighten his frustration. At home he can go at his own pace. He wants to finish a book in 1 week, that is his perogative. In school that is not an option.

What happens in the real world. Will his boss let him have 9 weeks to finish a project? What if Ian does it in 3 weeks, will the boss say, "No, I gave you 9 weeks, I don't want to see it until then." I think not. School is not real. My home life is real.

This is turning into a rant. If you have any questions, please feel free to E-mail me.

danette_jalil at yahoo dot com

MOM #1 said...

You know it never occurred to me to ask you why you homeschool. It's so funny once someone asks the right question, all the right answers start to spill out. I guess those of us who homeschool start to get a little jaded by knowing other like-minded people. That's a reminder that there are always people out there who can benefit from our stories.

You already know I love your blog, so that's besides the point, but thanks so much for giving a detailed reason as to WHY you home school. You need to link to that post and put a button on your blog for everyone to see. That experience you went through and SURVIVED is your warrior's badge of honor. I think every MOM has the obligation to fight hard and fierce for their children, no matter what.

Hurry for you. You WON!

Oh, and thanks for the happy anniversary. You know what's so sad, not only did I not realize it was my blogiversary, even after I read your comment . . . I went to bed thinking about it and didn't finally get it until the NEXT MORNING.

Maybe I shouldn't be homeschooling Baby Boy, LOL.

kitten said...

My oldest was way bored in school because they were going to slow. The other 2 had dyslexia. I got tired of dealing with them and pulled mine out. My heart got sick when my middle child wanted to go back. So far so good. I will put DJ in college classes next year (going on 16) He is getting above my head.
Kb is getting the attion she needs this year.
So, I guess it all is working out well.
Give me a little more time and I'll have more up on my new blog.
Hope there is something that can help you!

Jenn @ Juggling Life said...

It's a parent's job to advocate for their children--no matter the setting. It's great that you've found a solution that works for your family.

thislittlepiggy said...

I knew I was in trouble when I entered the room for Sweetums's IEP and they tried to make me take the only seat that was against the wall.

Great post. Thanks for sharing! :o)

The Old Gray Mare said...

Thanks for sharing your story!

I find that the one thing homeschool moms have in common is that we refuse to just give our kids over to "the system". There is not one set formula for educating our kids, and homeschool moms will keep working until we find what's best for our own unique child.

In our state hs kids are not allowed to participate in anything at the public schools. We are given options each year to sign up for certain services, but that requires letting the state into your home. No thank you.

Anonymous said...

Look - I'm famous on your blog! You told your story so well. I think so many families end up homeschooling out of frustration and then find out that it's a really good thing. I love reading about other family's "homeschool journeys"

Amy@thefoilhat.com